Rethinking doctoral assessment for a changing PhD

Author:
Dr Charlotte Fawcett
Published:

This blog was kindly authored by Dr Charlotte Fawcett, former HEPI intern and Pathways Outreach Assistant at De Montfort University.

For decades, PhD assessment has followed a broadly consistent model: candidates submit a written thesis before defending their research in an oral viva voce. Internal and external examiners use the viva to test the candidate’s understanding, establish ownership of the work and assess its original contribution to knowledge.

But as the PhD itself changes, an important question is becoming harder to ignore: does the traditional assessment model still adequately assess candidates, their work and their potential?

A model built around the monograph

The traditional PhD thesis is usually a monograph: a substantial, long-form work focused on a single subject and often written by a single author. This allows candidates to demonstrate sustained engagement with a research question and develop a coherent argument in depth.

However, the monograph may not be suitable for all types of PhD research. Increasingly, doctoral projects are collaborative: involving communities, organisations and industry partners, with contributions that extend beyond the written thesis. These ethical, social, community and policy contributions can be difficult to capture in an assessment model focused on individual research outputs.

This raises a broader question about what PhD assessment should recognise. If the purpose of a PhD is to demonstrate the ability to conduct rigorous, original research and contribute to knowledge, why should there be only one preferred way of demonstrating that achievement?

The viva: tradition under scrutiny

The viva is often presented as an essential and long-established feature of doctoral education. Its intellectual roots can be traced to traditions of oral disputation associated with Ancient Greece, where questioning and debate were used to test arguments.

There is a strong case for retaining this element of PhD assessment. The viva allows candidates to explain decisions that may not be apparent from the thesis, address weaknesses in their written work and demonstrate ownership of their research.

Yet tradition alone should not justify retaining a particular assessment method. In the UK, vivas are often conducted behind closed doors, raising questions about their transparency and validity. There are also concerns about whether the viva provides an equitable and reliable way of assessing candidates.

These concerns do not necessarily mean that the viva should be abolished. Instead, they demonstrate why one assessment format should not be treated as universally appropriate.

The problem with standardisation

The viva can be highly variable, with differences in questioning, examiner interactions and decision-making raising concerns about consistency. The format may also disadvantage some candidates, particularly those who experience anxiety or are neurodivergent. Vivas commonly last several hours and can involve significant costs, particularly when external examiners must travel.

It might be tempting to respond to these inconsistencies by making the viva more standardised. But this could solve one problem while creating another.

The diversity of doctoral research makes complete standardisation neither desirable nor necessarily possible. A two-hour oral examination may be appropriate for one candidate and discipline but poorly suited to another. A monograph may provide an excellent assessment of some research while being an inadequate representation of collaborative, creative, practice-based or community-engaged research.

The answer to inconsistency, therefore, should not necessarily be to make every PhD look the same. It should be to establish consistent expectations while allowing diverse forms of evidence.

Alternatives already exist

The traditional model can be adapted. Alternative thesis formats have long been used in disciplines such as music, drama and creative writing. Another established model is the journal or publication-based thesis. Candidates submit a series of peer-reviewed articles alongside introductory and concluding chapters that establish the coherence and contribution of the research.

These approaches demonstrate that doctoral assessment does not need to have a single format. They also highlight an important distinction – standardising the criteria for a doctorate is not the same as standardising the way those criteria are demonstrated.

A PhD should continue to meet robust expectations around originality, methodological rigour, critical thinking and contribution to knowledge. But candidates should have greater scope to demonstrate those qualities through outputs appropriate to their research.

From standardised processes to common standards

As the PhD continues to evolve, the range of outputs submitted for assessment is likely to expand.

Collaborative research may generate community resources, policy outputs or other forms of impact. Creative and practice-based research may require artefacts or performances. Digital research may generate datasets, software or other outputs that cannot be adequately represented through conventional means.

This does not mean that anything should count as a PhD. Greater diversity in assessment requires clearer principles, not weaker standards. Universities could establish a common framework defining what doctoral achievement means while giving candidates greater choice in how they demonstrate those achievements.

Reimagining doctoral assessment

There is an understandable institutional desire to standardise PhD assessment. Common processes can support quality assurance, consistency and comparability. But standardisation also has limits.

The PhD is, by nature, an individual research qualification. Research questions, methodologies, disciplines, outputs and collaborations vary enormously. A highly standardised assessment system risks producing consistency of process at the expense of validity of assessment.

We need common standards for what a doctorate represents, but greater diversity in how candidates demonstrate that they have achieved them.

This could mean broader recognition of different research outputs, greater consideration of collaborative and societal contributions, alternative approaches to the viva, and more flexibility for different disciplines and candidates.

The flaws in current PhD assessment should not lead us towards a more uniform system. They should prompt us to ask whether uniformity was ever the right goal. The future of doctoral assessment should be diverse by design, recognising the increasingly diverse ways in which PhD research creates knowledge and value.

Get our updates via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Comments

  • Andy Buckley says:

    I work in particle physics, probably the academic domain with the largest collaborations (frequently 3000 authors per paper). The degree of collectivity is why it’s so important to produce an extended write-up of your own ideas and contributions: somehow, students need to find their own niche and do something intellectually substantial and impactful within those vast teams. (In practice, not so hard: 3000 is relatively small compared to the scale of the challenge, and we are always short of people!) Despite the collaboration, a PhD is not just about being part of the big team: it has to be possible to identify your own ideas and research programme, in a way that PhD by 3000-author publication would not evidence.

    A thesis + viva is rather traditional, but is a clear way to practice explaining both the context and a narrative form of your own challenges and innovations. Of course it’s not all they do — there are complex datasets, software outputs, machine-learning models, you name it — but structuring and presenting a long-form argument is also a very useful skill (and a unique experience for most.) I don’t think I’ve ever seen “flaws” in the sense that thesis+viva assessment has let down an otherwise capable researcher.

    Agreed that the viva attendance shouldn’t be allowed to induce accessibility issues, but videoconference vivas are not a bad fallback option due to distance (e.g. they are standard in Australia/NZ due to geographical isolation and cost of getting _examiners_ there) or neurodiversity.

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

  • Laura Smith says:

    The monograph + closed door viva are the standard in the UK, but increasingly uncommon in an international context. This blog could be usefully extended with a cross-national comparison of doctoral assessment practices, aiming to identify good practice elsewhere.

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

  • John Quicke says:

    The role of the supervisor is crucial. Frequent discussions would be supportive, reveal the student’s grasp of the field, the nature of their own involvement, how their own input made a contribution and many other aspects that would be explored in a viva, but unlike a viva would be formative rather than summative. Of course, the student would always be aware that support and feedback involved some kind of assessment but unlike a viva this would not be high stakes. It would enable the student to show they had or had not made progress from one session to the next, and help them become more self critical and realistic about their own endeavours. If the supervisor hasn’t got the time to do this then there is no point in having a supervisor.

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

  • Jonathan Alltimes says:

    “A PhD should continue to meet robust expectations around originality, methodological rigour, critical thinking and contribution to knowledge. But candidates should have greater scope to demonstrate those qualities through outputs appropriate to their research.”

    Does the PhD work?

    The background to the argument is the economic value of research is big business and has political and social significance. The argument makes a distinction between common assessment standards and common assessment processes. The argument proposes freedom to choose how a candidate qualifies as a doctor of philosophy. But how can a teacher of philosophy be assessed other than by assessing the truth of the philosophy of their thesis? Scientific arguments are assessed by the causality of their hypotheses. Forensic arguments are assessed by the truth of historical causality and likelihood. Philosophies are assessed by the truth of their analogies, their principles, their meanings, and their logic. Research methodologies are philosophical arguments for how to conduct research for its purpose of original knowledge. In normal science, for the purpose of learning how to conduct research, methodologies are more or less settled, it is just a question of how to apply the methodology for new knowledge. Before cheap printing, all (philosophical) theses were argued in person. The viva is not the same as the text, as the text has different conventions, which vary. (More deeply, most Western academics no longer live in a worldview where they think the dynamic living Logos embodied in a person is true.) If the research works, a philosophical justification is unnecessary, in which case a teacher of philosophy is not required, except if we do not know how to cause new knowledge. How could we expect the truth of a philosophical justification for researching new knowledge without tests of its truth?

    Knowledge alone can not cause a civilization to endure.

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

  • Bre Green says:

    As someone who is considering pursuing a doctoral degree, I found this article particularly interesting. The traditional dissertation and oral defense have long been associated with doctoral education, but I can understand the argument that these methods may not fully reflect the different ways research is conducted today. Research is increasingly collaborative and interdisciplinary, and some projects produce outcomes that extend beyond a written document. I believe doctoral students should have opportunities to demonstrate their research abilities through approaches that are appropriate for their disciplines while still meeting rigorous academic standards.

    What I found most compelling was the distinction between maintaining consistent expectations and requiring everyone to demonstrate their knowledge in exactly the same way. In teaching, we recognize that students may demonstrate their understanding through different assessment methods, and I believe that same consideration can apply at the doctoral level. However, flexibility should not diminish the importance of original research, critical thinking, and scholarly accountability. Could incorporating more applied research projects, published studies, or community-based research into doctoral assessments better prepare graduates for the diverse professional roles they may pursue?

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

  • Dario Banegas says:

    Hi there! At Moray House School of Education and Sport, University of Edinburgh, we’ve just introduced the PGR (MScR and PhD programmes) by multimedia portfolio as another form of assessment…still followed by a viva. However, this is a crucial change!

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

Add comment

Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

More like this

A Policy Note on Higher Education Partnerships: how they can deliver fair access to higher education, whilst protecting policy, public funds and student outcomes. A new HEPI Policy…

Author
Dr David G Atkinson
Published
19 November 2026
Author
Jennifer Richards, Katherine Baxter, Kate De Rycker, Andrew Nash and Kathryn Walchester
Published
17 November 2026