Counted but not consulted: do students recognise widening participation support as being for them?

Author:
Dr Samantha Durrant
Published:

Following the issues with Microsoft, you may have missed some our recent blogs. To read Friday’s blog authored by Daniel Gilbert discussing HERA click here, or to read our weekend reading blog about the Renters Rights Act from Martin Blakey, click here.

This blog was kindly authored by Dr Samantha Durrant, Lecturer at the University of Manchester.

Universities collect extensive data about widening participation students, but how often do we ask those students what the label means to them or whether they recognise the support attached to it as being for them? 

Widening participation encompasses overlapping characteristics and circumstances,  including deprivation, ethnicity, disability, age and care experience, making it difficult to identify how many students meet these criteria. Office for Students data show that 24.9 per cent of full-time undergraduate entrants in 2023/24 came from the most deprived areas of England, yet institutional evidence remains stronger on who students are and the outcomes they achieve than on how they understand the widening participation label and the associated support available. 

Universities are increasingly expected to include the student voice as part of decision-making processes, but what is less often asked is how intended recipients understand the widening participation label itself, whether they recognise targeted provision as relevant to them, or why eligible students do not engage (Rahman, 2025). Academics and professional support staff may consequently design and communicate well-intentioned provision around assumptions rather than the needs of the students. 

In 2026, I surveyed 24 widening participation students at one UK university about how they understood widening participation, whether they identified with the categorisation, and how this related to belonging, participation and support. The study was small and exploratory, so its findings are tentative. However, the responses illuminate a gap that the broader institutional metrics alone cannot capture: the distance between being eligible for support and recognising that it is relevant, acceptable and accessible. 

The resulting paradox is that categories which reveal inequality at sector level can fail at the point of delivery. If students do not understand the terminology, identify with the label or feel able to disclose the circumstances behind it, provision that depends on self-recognition and self-referral misses many of its intended recipients. 

What students said 

Only 17 per cent of the students reported participating in or receiving targeted widening participation support, while a further 21 per cent were unsure whether they had received any. This does not establish that provision was absent but raises a more revealing question: can students identify widening participation support and recognise whether they are eligible for it? 

I wasn’t made aware that this was something I could seek extra support for.

Students valued widening participation as language for naming inequality, yet some felt uncomfortable when it was applied to them, associating it with pity, charity or being marked as different. Others met an institutional criterion without seeing themselves as disadvantaged. Eligibility is an administrative judgement; identity is personal and contextual. Treating the two as interchangeable risks designing support around a label that some intended recipients neither recognise nor accept. 

I don’t like that I’m placed in another category as other students, or that I’m labelled differently. 

Students reported concerns about belonging and representation, particularly those who met multiple widening participation criteria. Some felt different from peers who appeared more financially secure or familiar with university culture. These accounts suggest that a formally available service may still feel socially distant from the students it is intended to support. 

There is a wider conversation about not just participating in but thriving and belonging in higher education.

Students’ experiences also highlighted why support must be easy to recognise and use. Barriers included paid work, living costs, caring responsibilities and unfamiliar institutional processes. Without family experience of higher education, practical processes such as accommodation, registration, mitigating circumstances and graduation could feel daunting. The issue is not a lack of ability, but the expectation that students know how to independently find and interpret routes to information and support. 

Finally, students challenged the idea that widening participation students are a homogeneous group. They may meet one criterion or several, identify with disadvantage or reject that framing, and need different forms of support. They also described many positive aspects of their experiences, including resilience, self-advocacy, peer support and contributions to change. A shared category can reveal patterned inequality, but it cannot produce a shared identity or a single set of needs. 

What needs to happen next 

The answer is not simply more initiatives or categories, but provision designed around the whole student lifecycle from eligibility to recognition, trust and use. The Office for Students’ Equality of Opportunity Risk Register identifies unequal access to information and guidance, insufficient academic support and insufficient personal support as risks across the student lifecycle. Universities need to ask not only whether an intervention exists, but who knows about it, who uses it, who does not and why. 

Universities must involve students in designing, communicating and evaluating support. This should include students who did not engage, with a particular focus on understanding why. Communications should use clear, recognisable language and explain what support is available without requiring students to align with a particular identity. Wherever possible, services should reduce repeated self-disclosure, offer multiple routes into support and equip academic advisers to signpost sensitively without assumptions or stigma. 

Categories remain essential for exposing inequality, but successful widening participation cannot be judged by eligibility or provision alone. Institutions need to know whether students recognise support, trust it and can use it without stigma or unnecessary disclosure. Students should not only be counted within a category; they should help determine whether the support attached to it works. 

Get our updates via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Comments

  • Jonathan Alltimes says:

    I agree, users should be included in the design of services, but why do higher education institutions do not so so? It is mostly likely because of the cost implications of doing so. The service is designed to conform to the requirements of the OfS, as it is the OfS which uses the data and there is no institutional advantage for the institutions of higher education in redesigning the provision of services. Long and respected traditions exists in the economics of technological innovation research about the function of users in the design of industry products and in market research about the function of consumers in product or service design. The essential condition is understanding users and providers learn about the service, so disadvantaged students will need to learn how to use the services and should expect processes of learning how to use services. Services could be simple and standardised like a basic consumer product or complex and require customisation with service providers (Signposting requires assumptions and categorisation). As with many of the ideas about proposals in these blogs, what is lacking is a basic cost appraisal, that is, is the redesign and innovative provision going to cost an additional thousands of pounds per annum, tens of thousands of pounds, hundreds of thousands of pounds or millions of pounds. Institutions of higher education are not the first or only institutions who provide non-market based services for (disadvantaged) users, such as self-referral in general practice or social services. The next step is a qualitative study looking at one service of a particular institution for a particular user group, informed by the experience of the providers and how it can be of benefit to the user, the provider, and the OfS. As per normal, the OfS requirements presume a common statistical process causing outcomes in all providers.

    Reply

    Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

Add comment

Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.