Initial thoughts on the Milburn review
The Milburn review on NEETs (young people Not in Education, Employment or Training) has finally landed. It is a serious piece of work by someone who knows how Whitehall operates and, as such, deserves close and detailed scrutiny. No immediate response can do it full justice … Nonetheless, here is a list-icle with a few initial thoughts from HEPI’s CEO, Nick Hillman OBE, on how it reads at first sight.
- Like many official reports, it is riddled with somewhat overblown rhetoric. The early pages state: ‘Our country is at a fork in the road. … This is a moment of choice for the country. Half measures will not do. … A new approach is required, and so this is not a plan for doing the same things a little better. … This is not simply a cause for young people. It is a cause for the country. … A new settlement is needed if the lost generation is to become the work generation. … The task is to change the system itself. … Young people have not collectively failed the system. The system has failed too many of them. … The old Welfare State needs to evolve into a new Working State … A whole-system reset is required.’ I could go on but won’t. And at least the one section I put into the AI-detector Pangram came out with a (very) low AI score. The urgency and scope of the language are possibly calculated to mask the fact that the paper’s considered recommendations will take years to implement. Just as Net Zero comes to look all but impossible on the timeframe to which so many bodies – including universities – are committed and despite the fact that Alan Milburn’s Foreword says he dislikes the term ‘NEET’, we are now to have ‘NEET Zero’ – just not for another decade. And it turns out that ‘Zero’ actually means a youthful inactivity rate of 5% (or slightly more) rather than 0% – all the proposals together are designed ‘to help around 440,000 young people into sustained work by 2036.’ So however worthy or sound the recommendations might be, they are not going to transform hundreds of thousands of lives immediately and the spin may be running ahead of the substance.
- Alan Milburn wants, ‘270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts a year by 2036’. At one level, this looks ambitious and will doubtless be popular, given it is such a big increase. Milburn is surely right to want to see apprenticeships more focused on younger people, as tends to be common in other countries. At another level, it is significantly less ambitious than past (failed) promises: there were already 270,000 apprentice starts among under 25s in 2015, the year when David Cameron’s pledged to expand the scheme to deliver ‘three million new apprentices’. But after Cameron won the 2015 election, the numbers plummeted and have yet to recover. So Milburn is on to something important. Yet he does not adopt some of the bolder ideas for funding apprenticeships, such as moving degree apprenticeships on to the regular undergraduate fees and loans model That arguably could be a game-changer in terms of levelling the playing field between different degree routes and freeing up more resources for lower-level apprenticeships. So this is one area where the Government might wish to consider going further than Milburn suggests.
- It is obvious that the report has not been overseen by an educationalist, nor even a former education minister. Education is portrayed not as an end in itself but as a tool of the labour market. We are told: ‘Qualifications remain fundamental, but schools, colleges and universities must also be judged by whether young people make successful transitions into further learning and work.’ The problem with this is not the end goal so much as the path to get there, which reads like rather old-hat educational theories: ‘Schools must become engines of opportunity by gifting their students aptitudes and not just knowledge to better equip them for the future world of work.’ Like Amanda Spielman, I was left wondering if the Milburn team understand why English schools are currently doing so well, and are beating Wales and Scotland hands down on international rankings (such as the OECD’s Pisa tests). Meanwhile, as promised by a very long line of policymakers before him but never yet achieved, Milburn commits to parity of esteem, ‘Technical education should be on an equal footing with academic education.’ It might come as a surprise to some of those who work in education to hear that they have been acting somewhat slovenly to date: ‘the world of work is changing faster than the world of education.’ Intriguingly, University Technical Colleges, which have a mixed record, live on to fight another day, as Milburn wants to see ‘an expansion’ of them.
- The report balances the hackneyed with the politically fashionable, looking ahead to a world in which: ‘the process, power and accountability are devolved from the national to the local.’ Mayors are envisaged as having some specific new roles, as Milburn wants: ‘a mayor-led mechanism for developing new industry-led technical colleges, specialist campuses or equivalent centres.’ Perhaps bringing support down to a lower geographical area makes perfect sense in many circumstances. But as so often, it remains unclear what this means for those countless places that have yet to be affected by the uneven spread of devolution in England (and begs questions about capacity and experience even in some areas that have). Not everywhere resembles the political make-up of Greater Manchester or the Liverpool City Region.
- It is very statist, or perhaps corporatist. Although employers are seen as part of the solution to the NEETs crisis, they are not painted as organisations that should be freed to crack on with whatever it is each one does best, expanding their workforce along the way. Instead, they are to be partners in a new deal with society: ‘A new bargain is needed with employers to create more first chances for young people.’ It is all as far removed as imaginable from Liz Truss’s approach to resolving economic challenges by letting the market rip. In Milburn-land, policymakers will even keep sticks behind their backs for when employers do not do as expected, as with the report’s threat of ‘a mandatory disability employment quota for larger employers.’ There is a letter in The Times today headed ‘Real Neet causes’ from someone who runs an employment agency which makes the opposite case rather effectively, blaming costly increases in the minimum wage, National Insurance and the burden of regulation – in other words, meddlesome policymakers – for the growth in inactivity among young people.
- It is very bureaucratic. Take the headline changes to National Insurance to encourage the recruitment of young staff, which have been so heavily trailed in the media. These will not be across the board but implemented gradually, starting with one age group in one sector: ‘Rather than poorly targeted and unaffordable cuts in employer National Insurance, when fiscal conditions allow, it [the Government] should instead introduce a five-year glide path to lower employer National Insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24 starting in the retail and hospitality sectors’. A smooth glide may conjure up warm feelings (and assuage Treasury fears) but the problem with such protracted plans is young NEETS may mature and stop being young before they receive the help they need. And the longer they are NEET, the worse their long-term prognosis becomes. In short, those who like to caricature recent Labour administrations as committed-but-slow when it comes to tackling big social problems will find more meat here. (Certainly, this was the sort of line followed by right-of-centre outlets, such as the Guido Fawkes website and the morning email from The Daily Telegraph, even before publication.) On the other hand, the long-term and big-picture nature of the proposals are at one with the new Prime Minister’s commitment to a ten-year plan that will gradually ‘rewire the state’ and, on the BBC this morning, Nick Robinson was stressing that the Milburn report will call for big changes across nine separate government departments.
- It is very Blairite, including lots of fiddly new mechanisms but also ones that balance rights against responsibilities. A new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) would identity at-risk young people, meet with them, develop a personalised Participation Plan – and cut their benefits if it does not work: ‘Responsibilities have to sit alongside entitlements.’ It is also Blairite in the way that it paints rather obvious positions as brave choices: ‘I am unapologetic about advocating that the State should spend more to set young people up for a successful life earning or learning rather than spending decades with their sole income from benefits.’ Why would anyone think an apology for such a thought might be needed?
- There is a flavour of The Thick of It and its Fourth-Sector Pathfinder. Alongside the Youth Opportunity Service, the Opportunity Guarantee and the Support Guarantee, new initiatives should include, Milburn says, a ‘universal mental health digital front door’ and area-based ‘mandatory priority-cohort plans’. If nothing else, Stefan Collini would have fun dismantling the language in the way that he does for official papers on higher education. I can’t quite work out if the report’s initiativitis will make it harder to implement or harder to attack. Possibly both. It certainly made it easier to leak the ideas out one-by-one in advance of publication, and to such an extent that it made the whole concept of a media embargo rather redundant.
- The section on higher education commends universities for their recent but somewhat vague plans for more job-ready graduates: ‘Recent announcements by Universities UK to provide more work experience opportunities during study are welcome. That should become the norm over time. But more should be done to ensure universities focus on securing good employment outcomes for their students.’ Less mention is made, sadly, of the fact that a large majority of full-time undergraduates already do paid employment even during term-time, quite possibly meaning that the entry-level jobs that used to be performed by unskilled and low-skilled youngsters are less open to them. Oddly (and although economists disagree on the point), a quick way to help NEETs could be to improve maintenance support for full-time students, so that they do not so often need to fill available roles in order to pay their rent and other living costs and can focus more on their studies.
- As others have said before him, Milburn wants more higher education qualifications to be completed at Levels 4 and 5 as well as ‘annual step-off qualifications with portable credit, so that learners completing each year of higher education receive a recognised award’. He also says, ‘Strategic priority funding for tertiary education should be more directed towards subjects and routes linked to the Industrial Strategy, public service needs and regional priorities.’ But overall, the section on higher education feels a little confused or perhaps just undercooked. For example, we are told, ‘More towns should have a visible higher-education presence through satellite campuses, FE-HE partnerships or civic-university models, particularly where participation is low and regeneration need is high.’ That sounds sensible. The Chairman of the Office for Students himself put such plans in practice when he was Vice-Chancellor of Nottingham Trent University. But some of the report’s other comments feel redundant or off-topic; Alan Milburn reassures us, for example, that ‘There should not be a national curriculum for universities.’ Phew! And perhaps the biggest hole on universities (as with students) is in regard to funding. Other proposed changes are carefully costed whereas universities seem to be expected to do more with less (or, at the very least, more with no more).
Nick Hillman’s earliest think-tank publications include: A Raw Deal for Lone Parents: Evaluating the Evidence (2000), Left Out, Left Behind: The people lost to Britain’s workforce (2003) and Is Britain Working? A six-point action plan to increase employment rates (2005).





Comments
Add comment