WEEKEND READING: HERA at 10: the providers building the future of higher education 

Author:
Alex Proudfoot
Published:

This blog was kindly authored by Alex Proudfoot, Chief Executive of Independent Higher Education. 

On 16 May 2016, a quietly revolutionary document with the name Success as a Knowledge Economy slipped out of the Government communications machine and rippled across the higher education sector. The Higher Education and Research Act that followed would transform the architecture of a system failing to keep pace with the profound changes already affecting it. 

Participation had expanded, students were becoming more diverse, and specialist providers were already delivering higher education through more flexible and industry-focused routes. Funding increasingly followed students, but regulation remained rooted in an earlier world: an essentially closed group of publicly funded universities serving a predominantly young, full-time and residential population. 

England needed a more open system capable of supporting innovation and recognising excellent education wherever it emerged. 

One month later, a few dozen college principals and senior staff gathered in an unassuming room in a Georgian terrace on Bedford Square to reconstitute and relaunch Independent Higher Education: a powerful new identity for the voice of the independent sector at the beginning of a chapter overflowing with possibility. 

The timing was no coincidence – we had spent the previous year making the case for a more open, coherent and student-centred system. The reforms promised to give high-quality independent providers a permanent place within it, although certain events towards the end of June 2016 meant that higher education wouldn’t top the political agenda for long. 

Creating space for different answers 

Our 2015 election manifesto called for a comprehensive framework covering public and independent providers alike: universal registration, equitable access to funding, proportionate rather than uniform regulation, stronger student protection, portable credit and support for accelerated, blended, part-time and flexible study. Rather ambitiously, we also called for a Higher Education Bill by 2017. 

The Government did not simply adopt our proposals, and many others helped shape the settlement. But the same fundamental shift was clear: regulation should recognise quality rather than inherited institutional status. Ideas advanced from the margins had moved to the centre of policy. 

The genius of HERA was not that it predicted exactly what the university of the future would look like, but that it created space for different answers to emerge. 

A statutory Register, new routes to Degree Awarding Powers, student protection and proportionate regulation were intended to support a more diverse system. Student choice and, yes, competition were not side-effects. Innovation, new entry and academic autonomy were fundamental to HERA’s vision. 

Its architects understood that, in a period of rapid change, government could not prescribe a single model for the future. But it could create the conditions in which different institutions could test different answers, and students could decide which of them best met their individual needs. 

Students responded 

At IHE’s Annual Conference this week, we launched State of the Sector 2026, the first report in a new annual series combining official data with our own survey evidence to track the changing scale and impact of independent higher education. 

Independent providers in the public HESA data taught 76,275 students in 2018/19. By 2024/25, that figure had reached 169,805: growth of 123 per cent, compared with 13 per cent among traditional providers. UK student numbers at independent providers rose by 92 per cent, accounting for 28 per cent of all UK-domiciled growth across higher education. 

But the numbers are less interesting than what those choices mean for students. 

At Chickenshed, over 60 per cent of higher education students have an EHCP or disclosed disability. Teams of practitioners provide individual support without interrupting the session, while alumni mentors show students pathways into the profession. Inclusion is not added to the model, itt is an integral part of it. 

At Escape Studios, animation, visual effects and games students learn inside their industry. Professionals are embedded in course design, approval and assessment, and around 100 attend the annual student showcase. Industry is present throughout the experience, not waiting outside at graduation. 

At the Global Institute of Sport, students connect with an international sports industry through Global Summits from London to Melbourne and experiences such as its Live Lab at a football academy in Jamaica. 

At the National Motorsport Academy, students already working in motorsport study online, start in any month and turn live workplace projects into dissertations. Some also work with NMA’s professional race team. 

ASU London shows why HERA’s reform of Degree Awarding Powers mattered. Opening with its own powers allowed ASU London to recruit prospective engineers for their potential rather than their Level 3 Maths grade, providing the theoretical and Mathematical support they need while solving real-world problems. Its first cohort was 50 per cent female. 

These are not five versions of the traditional university but five very different ideas of what it means to be a higher education student. 

That is meaningful student choice: not simply choosing between institutions, but choosing between genuinely different experiences of learning and alternative career pathways.  

What they have in common is education designed around the lives and ambitions of their students, often embedded in a profession or industry and bringing academic learning, practical experience and personal development closer together. 

Ambition into reality 

Our report shows that these five institutions are vivid examples of a much wider pattern. 

First, independent providers reach students still too often treated as peripheral to the system. Nearly two-thirds of undergraduates at independent providers are mature, almost a third come from England’s most deprived areas and 58 per cent live at home while studying. Student choice is not simply about which campus an 18-year-old moves to. For many people, it is whether higher education can fit around employment, family, geographical ties and an already complicated life. 

Second, they are delivering the flexibility policymakers repeatedly say they want. Independent providers account for 96 per cent of the growth in part-time higher education since 2018/19. Eight in ten offer flexible study, and almost half intend to deliver modules through the Lifelong Learning Entitlement. 

Third, ambition is turning into action. Among providers responding to our survey in both 2025 and 2026, eight in ten now offer a qualification or mode of study they did not report a year earlier. Modular provision has doubled, while 86 per cent of providers partner with employers. 

Independent providers are not waiting for the future of higher education to arrive. They are building it. 

Their growth is about more than numbers. It is about young people immersing themselves in subjects they love, adults returning to education or changing direction, and professionals acquiring skills that help industries innovate. What connects them is purposeful learning and the opportunity to put theory into practice. 

The promise still incomplete 

HERA’s potential is becoming reality, but the system has not made it easy. Three-quarters of providers say their regulatory burden has increased over the past three years. None say it has fallen. Those working through university partnerships can experience regulation twice: directly and through requirements passed down by their partner. 

Innovation was supposed to be in the DNA of the Office for Students. It must have been a recessive gene, because it certainly skipped a few generations. 

New entrants were deprioritised, independent providers misunderstood and regulation allowed to ossify around the assumption that one size could fit all. Registration and Degree Awarding Powers were paused, leaving providers spending eye-watering sums extending validation agreements rather than investing in students and new provision. 

This is not a case for weaker regulation, but for regulation that protects students while enabling responsible growth, innovation and flexibility. Delay and uncertainty can close opportunities just as surely as poor provision can harm them. 

The impressively collaborative approach of the new OfS leadership offers an opportunity to recover HERA’s original ambition. Having been at the heart of the original reforms, they understand that ambition better than most. I have confidence that they will meet the moment. 

Government should see independent providers as willing and agile partners in growth, not exceptions to a university-shaped rulebook. Their contribution is already substantial. Policy should enable them to do more. 

The only constant is change 

In 2016, the White Paper and the legislation it inspired were needed because higher education had changed while its architecture remained rooted in the past. In 2026, HERA’s spirit must be recaptured because the sector faces what could be its greatest challenge yet – and one that only radical change may help it overcome. 

For decades now the threat of technology breaching the fortified towers of higher education and unravelling its value proposition has been ringing in our ears. Personal computers. The internet. MOOCs. In 2013, Michael Barber, who would later become the first Chair of OfS, famously warned that ‘an avalanche was coming’. But then the avalanche never seemed to arrive. 

Technology was transforming almost every other part of our lives, but the traditional tertiary pathway proved remarkably sticky: leave school at 18, go to university, study for three years, and then secure a graduate job. We have heard predictions of disruption so often that perhaps we have become like the villagers in the story of the boy who cried wolf. 

But AI may be the wolf

Young people now expect instant access to what feels like all the knowledge in the world, explained and personalised to them in seconds. If higher education is no longer the gatekeeper of knowledge, its value must increasingly lie in what our students do with it: the problems they solve, the judgements they make, the people they learn alongside, and the capabilities they develop. 

I do not pretend to know exactly what that means for universities in ten or twenty years and I am instinctively suspicious of anyone who says they do, but the answer is not that it means nothing. 

Longer working lives and rapidly changing industries also make education concentrated at the beginning of adulthood increasingly inadequate to the task at hand. We need progression at 18, 28, 38 and 58. The current Government’s post-16 reforms and the Lifelong Learning Entitlement point towards a more flexible, specialised and comprehensive system of lifelong higher learning. 

HERA was not the beginning or the end of that story. But ten years after the White Paper, it remains one of its most important chapters. Its spirit was confidence in the agency of students, belief in the value of diversity, and trust in the capacity of new institutions to produce new and sometimes better answers to the questions that we all face.  

Today the world in which higher education takes place is changing once again. This time, regulation cannot be the last part of the system to notice. 

Get our updates via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Comments

Add comment

Your comment may be revised by the site if needed.

More like this

A Policy Note on Higher Education Partnerships: how they can deliver fair access to higher education, whilst protecting policy, public funds and student outcomes. A new HEPI Policy…

Author
Dr David G Atkinson
Published
19 November 2026
Author
Rob Phillpotts
Published
18 November 2026